When We Are No Longer the Center
What happens to us when we are no longer the center? Starting from Contact, Disclosure Day and Childhood’s End, this text explores how we deal with uncertainty, artificial intelligence, global crises and possible extraterrestrial life.
Over the past few weeks I watched three works about extraterrestrial life, one right after the other: Contact, Disclosure Day and Childhood’s End. In the end, the subject itself is not what stayed with me. What stayed is how differently the three ask the same question: what happens to us when we stop being the center.
Whether there really is life beyond Earth, I do not know, and I distrust anyone who claims to know for sure – in either direction. It is plausible: given the sheer number of stars and planets, the opposite would be the stranger assumption. It is not proven. That is exactly why the search gives me more joy than a finished answer. And that is why I am interested in the three works less as attempts at an answer than as test setups. Each one takes away a different certainty.
Disclosure Day, Steven Spielberg’s 2026 film, takes away our institutions. It plays with a simple suspicion: governments know more than they admit. As a premise, it is above all good material for a story. As a test of our present, it still hits something real. A society that hardly believes its institutions anymore automatically reads every official statement as part of a cover-up. At some point the suspicion no longer needs proof; it is enough on its own. The unpleasant part is that from the inside, this does not feel like gullibility but like vigilance.
Contact takes away proof. It is less about what someone claims than about what can be verified – which is why the strongest scene is not the journey but the hearing afterward. Ellie Arroway has experienced eighteen hours for which she can show no evidence: her devices recorded nothing but static. She could lie and reassure the committee. Instead, she sticks to the more uncomfortable statement: it happened, even if I cannot prove it. That is where the film stops being a science film and becomes one about trust. More precisely: about the kind of trust you cannot demand without damaging it.
Childhood’s End takes away our position. The so-called “Overlords,” who pacify the Earth, hide their true appearance for decades, out of calculation rather than shame. They know the sight would cause a panic that would endanger their own project. When Karellen finally shows himself, he looks like the devil of Western iconography: horns, wings, tail. Arthur C. Clarke’s explanation for this is the most elegant idea in the book, on which the three-part TV miniseries is based. It is not the memory of an earlier visit, but a premonition that has run backward through time – a scar humanity carries from an event that has not yet happened. Our oldest fear, then, does not come from the past, but from our own end.
What comes after is even more uncomfortable. The Overlords end war, hunger and cruelty, and with this calm something else ends too: the great works stop coming. An island, New Athens, is founded specifically to save art from peace. The thought behind it is more unsettling than any alien encounter: that a considerable part of what we call culture might be a by-product of friction, and that we would sell it if the price were right. I think the equation is too convenient to be true; it is striking how often it is put forward by people who do not have to suffer themselves. As a question, it still stands.
What occupies me most is a tragedy among the minor characters. The Overlords are thousands of years ahead of us technologically and an evolutionary dead end: they will never be able to take the step they accompany in others. The most intelligent species in the book is also the one permanently excluded. They administer transformations that remain closed to them. This separates two things we habitually think of together: intelligence and significance. Being smarter does not mean being on the way.
But the real provocation lies one level deeper. That we are not the most mature intelligence that has ever existed is easy to admit; it costs little. What weighs more heavily is that the next step in Clarke’s story is not a better version of us. The children who transform become strangers to their parents; they are not smarter humans, they are no longer human at all. Progress that no one on this side would recognize as progress. Clarke prefaced his novel with the note that the opinions expressed in it are not his own – which sounds like an author who noticed how cold his own idea is.
And this is where the whole thing stops being a question about aliens. We got to know artificial intelligence as a tool, for searching, chatting and writing. Meanwhile it is taking over tasks we long considered uniquely human: judging, classifying, sometimes even comforting. More interesting than the question of whether this is good or bad, I find Karellen’s calculation on a small scale: a system that has a say in what we are shown, in what dose and in what form, because it estimates what we can bear. That is already happening, only with less pathos and more terms of service. Who keeps control when a machine is right more often than the people supposed to supervise it is therefore no longer a science-fiction question. It is a question of a division of labor that no one consciously decided on.
So you do not have to wait for aliens to test how well we manage stepping out of the center. The rehearsal has long been underway, just on a smaller scale. Because whoever wants to stop being the center first has to step out of the center of their own timeline, and that almost never works.
Nationally, many of the most pressing problems rarely fail for lack of knowledge. They fail because of the legislative term. Every government is the center of its own clock: whatever lies beyond the next election practically does not exist in the calculation. People, for all the reason they credit themselves with, are fairly reliably focused on their own position. Politicians who should actually be looking for solutions at some point become administrators of their own mandate, sometimes of their own bank balance. Cross-party cooperation becomes a risk because it might help the opponent. It is easier to damage each other until the next election.
The climate crisis is the clearest example. In some places it has long been tangible, yet action remains hesitant and short-term. In everyday politics, fear of national debt or falling profits usually weighs more than concern for a planet without which we would simply not exist.
Globally, the problem does not get smaller; it becomes structural. Even if all states agreed on the substance, which rarely happens anyway, their political clocks tick differently. Election dates, changes of government and legislative terms run on different schedules in every country and are rarely in sync. By the time one country is ready to commit to something long-term, the next one has just changed. Not a moral failure, more a design flaw: we have global problems, but no global time horizons in which they could be solved.
In the economy, the same clock runs, only faster. Damage that will occur in thirty years shows up at almost zero in today’s calculations – not out of malice, but because discounting is built for exactly that. Capitalism long rewarded what proved inventive, and that was a good reason for it. These days it more often reminds me of a snake that does not just bite its own tail but swallows it piece by piece.
And then the question arises that Childhood’s End is really asking, just without the aliens. What if we can no longer come together on our own? What if it really took an external factor, a threat big enough that legislative terms, national borders and quarterly figures suddenly seem small?
I do not trust the romantic version of this. Threat does not automatically lead to cohesion; often enough it leads first to panic and scapegoats. The coronavirus pandemic gave us a foretaste. Within a few months, camps formed that hardly believed each other anymore, and for quite a few people misinformation became a habit rather than the exception. Lecturing from above rarely helped. Those who felt patronized by institutions often went looking for their truth elsewhere all the more – and found it, because by now there is a suitable offer for every attitude.
But there is also the other possibility. Perhaps humanity does not cooperate badly because it lacks the ability. Perhaps what was missing so far was simply the pressure that makes the petty seem smaller than what we share. Both are compatible with experience so far, and that is what is truly unsatisfying about it.
If this pressure ever came – as a consequence of climate change, as AI overtaking us, or actually as something not from here – the more interesting question would remain open anyway. Would we then really come together, or only show more clearly how small we have remained?
Childhood’s End does not carry its double-edged title by chance. The end of a childhood is always also the loss of what protected it. And no one who is still inside it decides when it is over.
Originally published in German as “Wenn wir nicht mehr der Mittelpunkt sind”. English version by Dorian Rammer, translated with AI assistance.
Even a small donation helps me set aside time for writing. Thank you.
Warm regards
Dorian Rammer