Michael Jackson and the Dispossession of a Human Being
A TikTok clip of Dick Gregory becomes the starting point for an essay on Michael Jackson’s power behind the scenes: music rights, Sony/ATV, media images, acquittal, decline – and the question of who owns art, and eventually a person, when everyone profits from him.
I saw a video on TikTok: a man named Dick Gregory stands giving a talk, holding a few sheets of paper, reading out names. One after another. Unhurried.
The Beatles. Bob Dylan. Beyoncé. Eminem. Dolly Parton. Bon Jovi. Babyface. Boyz II Men. Queen. The Rolling Stones. Stevie Wonder. Taylor Swift. Lady Gaga. Shakira. Leonard Cohen. Joni Mitchell.
And the names don’t stop. (Twenty-two pages long.)
Gregory was a comedian and civil rights activist, one of those older Black men in America who had truly lived political resistance with their own bodies – with arrests, hunger strikes in the public eye, risk, a real price. He knew Michael personally and stood by him during his most difficult times. And his message in this lecture was roughly: Look at this list. Understand what it means. And then ask yourselves why this man died the way he died.
For Gregory, this list was no simple name-dropping. It was meant to show that Michael Jackson was not only a singer, dancer, entertainer, pop star, but that behind the scenes he held something less visible than fame and often more powerful: the question of who owns music, who profits from it and who decides its second life, long after the applause is over.
This has to be said carefully, because otherwise it quickly sounds wrong: Michael did not simply “own Beyoncé or Eminem.” That is not how music rights work. It wasn’t about people, but about publishing shares, catalogs and exploitation rights – about who earns from songs, who may license them and who has a say in which film, which advertisement or which business context they later appear in.
That was the core of it. Michael didn’t just succeed within the music industry. He moved more and more into the area where decisions about artists are usually made: not on the stage, but behind the contracts; not in the applause, but where ownership, control and the future of a work are negotiated.
That is a fundamental difference.
Because for decades the standard rule of this industry was brutally simple: the artist supplies voice, body, youth, discipline and often enough their whole life – while control over the work stays with those who manage, market and resell it. Black artists in particular were treated exactly like this for many decades: celebrated as long as they functioned. Exploited as long as money flowed. Replaced as soon as they became inconvenient.
Michael didn’t know this only from books. He had lived it himself – early, as a child, as someone who had to function before he even knew what he himself actually wanted.
In 1985 he bought the ATV music catalog. In 1995 he merged it with Sony’s publishing arm to form Sony/ATV, fifty-fifty. He secured his own songs through Mijac Music. With that, Michael had become a power behind the scenes of the music business like no other artist. Not because he sold more records than others, but because he had understood where the real power lies: not only in the applause, but in owning the rights.
By 2016, when Sony paid $750 million for the Jackson estate’s remaining 50 percent stake in Sony/ATV, the scale of it was plain to see. But it was never really just about a sum. It was about influence. About control. About the question of who decides how music lives on when the artist himself has long left the room.
And he began – as I read him – to think things that many artists of his generation did not yet think: that control is not a luxury. That it is a backbone. That a work is more than a product. And that art, once it has been drawn out of a human being, should not simply become an asset at the disposal of corporations.
I don’t believe greed drove him. Of course it was also business. Michael was clever, much smarter than the media later portrayed him. But with him, business sense and conviction were never neatly separate. He wanted art to rest with the people who truly mean it. He didn’t want artists to pour their lives into works that in the end hardly belong to them anymore. He wanted a real say. Dignity. A share of the power back.
And in this industry, that doesn’t win you friends.
In the early 2000s things became really serious. Tommy Mottola, head of Sony Music, became the symbol of this conflict. In July 2002, in Harlem, Michael publicly called him a racist and “very, very, very devilish,” then rode past Sony’s headquarters in New York on an open-top double-decker bus, and declared that the music industry systematically exploited Black artists.
Many media treated this as yet another sign of his decline. As spectacle. As proof that he had lost his footing for good.
I think it was rather the other way round.
This was one of those moments when someone, with the last of his strength, said exactly what he meant. Emotional, unstrategic, probably dangerous – but not without reason. Michael wasn’t attacking just any manager. He was attacking a system that over decades had learned to treat artists as raw material: voices, faces, movements, stories, bodies – usable as long as they function.
And the industry he had publicly shamed answered in its own way. Not loudly. Power rarely needs to raise its voice.
Then, in 2003, came the allegations.
Here I want to say clearly what I believe:
Michael Jackson was a good-natured person. That sounds simple. It isn’t. Good nature on this scale – with this fame, this vulnerability, this money, this public exposure – is not a harmless trait. It is an open door. For opportunists. For bad advisers. For people who want closeness without being honest. For people who could profit from his generosity without taking responsibility.
You can be the most famous person in the world and still have no one who tells you: This isn’t good for you. Don’t go there. Don’t trust this person. You don’t always have to give.
The allegations, the trial, the media – this didn’t hit some stable superstar with a thick skin. It hit someone whose inner foundation was already damaged. Someone who was never really allowed to be a child. Who had to function early. Who had learned to earn love through performance. And who had given his longing for innocence, for an unbroken world, for a real childhood a home in Neverland – not out of darkness, as I understand it, but out of a deeply wounded yet fundamentally good longing.
That is exactly why this accusation was the cruelest attack imaginable. Not only on his name, his career, his public image, but on that inner place he himself had always associated with children, protection, healing and innocence. The man who for decades had channeled income, attention and millions into charitable projects, supported hospitals and kept speaking about wanting to heal the world was struck precisely where his values were most vulnerable.
The media turned this into the image of a monster.
Back then that was possible in a way hardly imaginable today. No social media. No direct counter-public. No way to bring one’s own version, unfiltered, to millions. Tabloids, talk shows, television, newspapers – they could shape an image, repeat it, nail it down. And that is exactly what they did.
An accusation needs a headline. A defense needs time. A scandal sells in seconds. A correction only interests those who were going to look more closely anyway.
This creates a brutal asymmetry: the damage becomes a mass product, the exoneration becomes specialist knowledge.
And this asymmetry didn’t only hit the allegations. It hit his whole body. His changed skin color, his face, his operations, his illnesses, his vulnerability – everything became a surface for others to project onto. In the tabloids, illness turned into suspicion, vulnerability into a punchline, a person with visible scars into a public object people were allowed to laugh at.
The greatest entertainer in the world became a “freak.”
And no one listens to a “freak” anymore when he talks about rights, dignity and exploitation.
For me, this is where the bigger question lies. Not only: Who owns art? But: Who owns the truth about a human being when enough others profit from distorting him?
With Michael, it wasn’t simply that people reported on him. People profited from him: from his genius, his otherness, his vulnerability, from the allegations, from his pain and finally also from his collapse. The media didn’t just accompany him. They helped shape him. At some point the public image was stronger than the person behind it.
Maybe that is the most brutal form of dispossession: not only that companies profit from your songs, but that a public eventually believes your face, your body, your childhood, your soul and your truth belong to it as well.
Anyone who sells records by the millions is eventually treated as if the world had bought not just music, but a piece of a human being.
Dick Gregory’s thesis – that Michael’s position of power, his rebellion against the industry, his rights and catalogs contributed to his downfall – to my mind, is not wrong. Anyone who becomes inconvenient in an industry with billion-dollar interests, who no longer just sings but speaks publicly about exploitation and won’t be stopped, attracts forces that would rather be rid of him.
I don’t say this as a thriller.
I say it as an analysis of capitalism.
Because whoever reads Michael’s end only as a story about medication makes it too easy. Yes, at the end there were drugs. Yes, at the end there was propofol. Yes, at the end there was a doctor, a body that could no longer come to rest, and a system of dependence, pressure and medical irresponsibility.
But before that, there was more.
Before that there was a man who had made powerful enemies. An artist who didn’t only shine on stage but held rights behind the scenes, controlled catalogs, spoke out publicly against exploitation and thereby touched something far more sensitive in this industry than image: ownership.
Michael’s decline was not a simple result of his position of power. It was the result of a web that no single explanation can account for.
The industry. The media. Bad people in his closest circle. A trial he won in 2005 on all ten counts – but whose acquittal never got the same cultural volume as the accusation.
Because what does it say about a society when a person is acquitted but continues to be treated like a convicted man?
What does it say about how we arrive at the truth when the acquittal stays quieter than the suspicion?
At the end of his life he could no longer sleep. Not just sleep badly – apparently he could hardly come to rest at all. He was given propofol, an anesthetic used for surgery. That is what killed him.
I find this thought almost unbearable: a man who made the world dance could himself no longer find a way to rest.
That is more than a medical detail. It is an image. His body had forgotten how rest works. The noise, the pressure, the fear, the loneliness, the betrayal – at some point not even sleep was left.
And that’s why it doesn’t surprise me that to this day so many artists name him not just as an influence, but as a starting point. The Weeknd has said that Michael is everything to him, and that Off the Wall was the album that inspired him to sing. Beyoncé speaks not about dance steps, but about feeling. Others name his discipline, his precision, his videos, his courage, his control over the whole of his work.
That is no coincidence.
I believe this gratitude has to do with more than the moonwalk, the voice or pop genius. It also has to do with the fact that Michael showed what is possible. That a Black artist doesn’t have to shine on stage and obey behind it. That you can hold rights. That you can take on corporations. That art should be protected, because there is not only market value in it, but life.
And maybe also simply: he was good. In a business that rarely rewards goodness.
With his list, Dick Gregory wanted to say that this man was not powerless.
That’s true.
But power doesn’t replace protection. Rights don’t replace honest friends. Fame doesn’t replace a sense of being held. And no catalog in the world gives back to a person what was taken from him as a child.
He had rights, money, visions, influence.
And in the end he could no longer sleep.
For me, that is the real story.
Originally published in German as “Michael Jackson und die Enteignung eines Menschen”. English version by Dorian Rammer, translated with AI assistance.
Even a small donation helps me set aside time for writing. Thank you.
Warm regards
Dorian Rammer