> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.widerstandskraft.link/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# How Are You? A Question That Doesn’t Want an Answer
- URL: https://www.widerstandskraft.link/en/how-are-you-a-question-that-doesnt-want-an-answer/
- Published: 2025-10-25T08:46:16.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-12T13:11:40.000Z
- Description: “How are you?” – the politest escape of our time. On small talk and depression, sensory overload, helping and listening – and on why it takes courage simply to stay honest when the world only wants quick answers.
- Author: Dorian Rammer
- Tags: Mind & Health, Society & Our Times, Childhood & Trauma, Resilience & Inner Strength, autobiographical, #en

---

The first version of this text began as a very personal diary entry on my old blog. I have since revised, expanded and reordered it – not because the feelings have changed, but because my view has sharpened.

“How are you?” – a seemingly harmless question that occupied me then and still does now. It stands for closeness that doesn’t quite happen, and for the effort of answering honestly. Perhaps it is less a question than a mirror: how much authenticity can we really bear?

In the years since the first version, I have learned a lot about depression. About my depression. About the patterns that repeat. About [the crises that came](https://www.widerstandskraft.link/en/silence-does-not-protect-on-trauma-addiction-and-going-on-living/) – some worse than back then. And about the paths that can really help. Not always. But sometimes.

*“Sometimes the most honest answer to ‘How are you?’ is silence.”*

---

### \[The Event\]

“Come along, it’ll do you good. You need to be around people again.”

I didn’t want to. I really didn’t. But I thought, maybe he’s right. Maybe I just need to get out. Movement. Distraction. Anything that gets me out of bed. So I said yes.

The event was a mistake. Too many voices, too much perfume, too much light. Everything vibrated in my head. I stood there with a glass in my hand and pretended I belonged. At the rim of the glass I smelled lemon and metal. It made me dizzy. But I was on a completely different wavelength. The conversations around me – shallow, loud, meaningless – or so it felt. Maybe it was just me. Depression distorts perception. It makes everything gray, makes everything exhausting.

“So how are you, actually?”

My companion. Between two conversations with people he knew. He glanced at me briefly, but his eyes were already somewhere else. His mind was on the event, on everything around it, on everything except me. The question was a phrase. A courtesy. Not a real invitation.

I could have said: Badly. I can’t stand this for another five minutes. Could have said: I’m only here because I thought I had to be around people, but that was a mistake. Could have said: I don’t know how I’m going to get through next week.

“All good.”

He nodded, smiled, turned away. Done.

Between us a chair stayed empty, though there was none.

I stayed another half hour, then made up an excuse and disappeared. On the way home my shoulders relaxed. At the same time a knot tightened in my stomach. Why am I like this? Why can’t I do this?

Later, in bed, I thought he didn’t mean any harm. He probably really did want to know how I was. But he had no time for the answer. And I didn’t have the strength to give it to him.

---

### \[The Mechanics of Small Talk – What It Covers Up\]

“How are you?” is the most frequently asked and least meant question of our time.

That is no exaggeration. It is a social reflex so deeply ingrained that we hardly notice it anymore. We say it in passing, on the subway, at the supermarket, in the office. The body responds on its own: [smile, nod, keep walking](https://www.widerstandskraft.link/en/the-eyes-of-others-eye-contact-and-insecurity/). The tongue is faster than the heart. We ask without wanting to know – and answer without saying anything.

The sociologist Erving Goffman called this “face-work”: we play roles to make social interaction easier. “How are you?” is part of this façade, a ritual gesture that signals: I see you. I’m polite. I’m fulfilling my social duty. Nothing more.

The problem: this façade protects us from discomfort, but it also makes us lonely. Because behind the phrase lies a silent agreement: we both pretend everything is fine. And if one of us breaks this agreement – if someone answers honestly – the system collapses. Then you stand there, overwhelmed, because you suddenly get more than you expected.

I have experienced this myself. Someone answered my superficial “How are you?” honestly. And I was taken aback. I didn’t know what to say. I had no time, no emotional budget for a real answer. So I did what most people do: I smiled, mumbled something encouraging and moved on.

Later came the guilt. The shame. Because I realized: I’m no better. I play the same role. I ask questions I don’t mean. I demand honesty I don’t give myself.

---

### \[Conversations with Friends – When Even Closeness Isn’t Enough\]

With strangers, you can hide behind “All good.” With friends, it gets more complicated.

Because good friends notice when you lie. They ask again. They really want to know how you are. And that is exactly the problem.

I tried to be honest. A few times. Started to tell them how I really was. That I can’t get out of bed. That I escape into dream worlds because reality is too heavy. That I no longer know how to get through the week.

They listen. Really. But at some point I see it in their faces: a small helplessness. A sense of being overwhelmed. A silent: I don’t know what to say.

And then usually one of these sentences comes:

“It’ll get better.”  
“You should get out more.”  
“You know, other people don’t always have it easy either.”

And you know what? They’re not completely wrong. There is a spark of truth in each of these sentences. Life moves. There are highs and lows. Sometimes exercise helps. And yes, many people suffer – it can be comforting to know you’re not alone.

But in the moment when you’re sitting at the bottom of the valley and the darkness is so thick you can’t see your hand in front of your face – that spark of truth doesn’t help. Because the problem isn’t that you don’t *know* it. It’s that you can’t *feel* it.

“It’ll get better” may be true. But it doesn’t change the fact that right now it’s unbearable.

It’s not meant badly. On the contrary. But it doesn’t help. Because these aren’t solutions, but reflexive attempts to ease the other person’s own discomfort. They want the conversation to get lighter again. They want me to relieve them of the burden of having to deal with my pain.

Depression is hard to grasp. You can’t fix it with good advice. You can’t comfort it away. And I know my friends want the best for me. But sometimes the feeling still arises: I’m too much. My pain is too big. I should keep it to myself.

So I withdraw. Answer “All good” again. And notice the distance growing. Not because they don’t like me. But because I have learned that honesty can make you lonely.

I know it overwhelms them, because I don’t understand myself. Depression is hard to explain – even to myself.

---

### \[Depression: What It Really Means Not to Function\]

Depression is not sadness. Sadness is a feeling. Depression is the absence of feeling. It is an emptiness. A gray that covers everything.

I have suffered from depression since my youth. My mother did before me – she was severely depressed and has passed away. Early burdens in my childhood probably played their part, but I will write about that in more detail elsewhere. For a long time I thought it was in the past, back in 2017, when I was doing better. But depression isn’t the flu, something you go through once and are then immune to. It comes back. Quietly. Creeping. And suddenly you’re lying there again, thinking: Not again.

Now, years later, that is a realization both bitter and liberating: for me, depression is a chronic matter. A companion that sometimes grows quieter, sometimes louder. In the meantime I’ve had crises worse than the time I wrote the first draft of this text. But I understand better now what is happening to me. I recognize the patterns earlier. That doesn’t make it easier. But it makes it less foreign.

**Worth knowing:** Depression takes very different courses. For some people a depressive episode subsides after weeks or months and never returns. Others experience recurring episodes over years. Still others – like me – live with a chronic form, in which the symptoms persist over long periods. There are people who live with depression for 40 years and longer. Depending on the definition, roughly a fifth to a third of depressions take a chronic course. Some barely respond to treatment. That is not rare. It is not a personal weakness, but the reality of this illness.

It’s the quiet days that eat you up. Not the dramatic breakdowns. But the days when getting up is too hard. Not because you’re tired, but because the world outside is too loud, too fast, too much.

Some days I just lie in bed. Literally. For hours. Freeze. Head in the sand. Or rather: in a dream world. Because reality is unbearable. Because my body feels like lead. Because every thought of the tasks waiting for me – answering emails, going shopping, meeting people – exhausts me before I’ve even started.

But this isn’t laziness. It isn’t a decision. It isn’t a failure of will, but a short circuit in the system. My brain switches to emergency mode, and then even showering becomes an expedition. The chemistry slips – or at least that is how it feels: serotonin, dopamine, noradrenaline thrown into disarray. The part that organizes drive goes on strike. And then you sit there, staring at the wall, thinking: I should. But I can’t.

I escape into my head. Into daydreams. Into stories I tell myself. Not metaphorically. Literally. I live more in my imagination than in reality. Because everything is easier there. Because there I don’t have to feel how heavy everything is.

And then when someone asks, “How are you?” – what am I supposed to say? Today I managed to get dressed. That’s my success! I haven’t answered messages for three days because it overwhelms me. I don’t know if I’ll be able to get up tomorrow.

That doesn’t fit into small talk. That doesn’t fit anywhere.

---

### \[When the Body Speaks Too – Sensory Overload and Its Roots\]

About 15 to 20 percent of people are highly sensitive. In psychology this is called “sensory processing sensitivity”: the nervous system processes stimuli more intensely. You perceive more. You feel more. You become overstimulated faster.

But heightened sensitivity can also be a consequence of psychological strain, or be amplified by it. People who have lived with depression, anxiety disorders or the aftermath of trauma for a long time often develop an increased sensitivity to stimuli. [The nervous system is constantly on alert](https://www.widerstandskraft.link/en/dis-ease-health-is-a-reserve/). The filtering of important and unimportant information no longer works properly. Everything gets in. Everything is too much.

I no longer know exactly what came first. Whether I’m more sensitive by nature or whether the years of psychological struggle made me this way. Probably both. What I do know: I sense moods before anyone says anything. I notice when someone is tense, sad, angry – even when they’re smiling. I pick up nuances others miss.

On the subway, for example. The announcements, too shrill. The squeal of the brakes, too piercing. The bodies around me, too close. I take in everything – and at the same time I’m numb with sensory overload. My head hums. My skin tingles. I just want out.

Or at the supermarket. The neon lights. The background music. The people crowding the aisles. All too much. I quickly buy what I need and leave. But afterwards I’m exhausted, as if I’d run a marathon.

And when I then sense that someone is asking me “How are you?” but doesn’t really want an answer – it hurts twice. Once for the superficiality. And once for the realization that I do exactly the same thing.

I’m no better. I’m just as overwhelmed when someone answers honestly. I don’t know what to say either. I also withdraw when it gets too much.

But that’s exactly what makes it so hard: patterns that wear you down – and stay.

The combination of depression and sensory overload is treacherous. The depression empties me, while the oversensitivity floods me with everything. I feel too much and too little at the same time. I’m overstimulated and burned out. I want closeness and can’t bear it.

That leads to a vicious circle: I withdraw because social situations overwhelm me. But withdrawal makes the depression worse. So I force myself to go out – like to that event. But then I notice that it’s too much. So I withdraw again. And so on.

---

### \[The Samariterbund – When Helping Becomes an Escape\]

I was a paramedic with the Samariterbund, an Austrian rescue and ambulance service. Not because of the calls with flashing lights. But because of the moments in between. The elderly people we drove home. The conversations in the ambulance. The woman who told us her husband had died and she didn’t know how to go on living alone. The man who apologized for causing us trouble, even though he had just had a heart attack.

That was what gave me something. These psychosocial moments. The human in between. I sensed things others missed. Nuances. A fear someone didn’t put into words. A shame. A loneliness. Sometimes I understood more about a person’s state than colleagues who had been doing this for years. Not because I was better. But because I know myself what it’s like to be ashamed. To not want to be a burden. To function on the outside while you’ve long been collapsing inside.

Perhaps I was good at it precisely because I was fighting there myself.

But at some point that wasn’t enough anymore. The sick leaves piled up. Once, twice, then again. I felt the looks. The unspoken question: Is he resilient? Can we rely on him? I didn’t want to be the one who drops out. Who blows the shift because once again he can’t get out of bed. So I asked to end my employment. Not because I didn’t want to anymore – but because I couldn’t anymore.

Only months later did I understand the pattern. As long as I was taking care of others, I didn’t have to take care of myself. Caring for others was easier than caring for myself. I could listen to a stranger who had lost her husband. But I couldn’t deal with my own grief. I could take away someone’s shame about needing help. But I couldn’t let go of my own.

Helping gives you the feeling of being worth something – without having to face what is broken inside you. You’re busy. You’re important. You’re needed. And all of that feels better than the question: What if nobody needs me? What am I then?

The farewell felt like betrayal. But maybe it was the first honest decision in a long time. The first one where I admitted: I need help myself. I can’t only give anymore. I have to take as well.

But admitting that feels like failure.

After the farewell there was silence. And in that silence I began to understand what listening really means.

---

### \[The Silence in the Room – Why Listening Is So Hard\]

What we really need are not answers. But presence.

Hard to understand in a world geared toward solutions. Toward efficiency. Toward productivity. We are conditioned to solve problems. So when someone has a problem, we want to fix it. We want to help. We want it to get better.

But sometimes that doesn’t help. Sometimes it makes everything worse.

Because when someone talks about depression and immediately gets advice – “Have you tried exercise?” “Maybe you should take vitamin D?” “You have to think more positively!” – the message is: your pain is a problem I have to solve so that I can feel comfortable again.

What we need instead is listening. Just listening. Without judging. Without evaluating. Without fixing.

But that is incredibly hard. Because listening means: I can bear your pain. I stay, even when it’s uncomfortable. I endure the silence. I endure not knowing.

How often does that really happen? How often does someone simply stay when you say, “I’m not doing well”? No advice. No cheering up. Without trying to make the situation more bearable – for themselves.

Rarely. Damn rarely.

Maybe that is the core of the problem. We have unlearned how to deal with pain – other people’s, but also our own. We have unlearned how to bear that sometimes everything is shit and there is nothing you can do about it. We have unlearned how to simply be there.

Listening. Really hearing. Talking less yourself. This is not a passive role. It is one of the most active forms of care there is. But it demands something that has become rare: endurance.

---

### \[My Own Learning Process – Awareness Without Healing\]

I don’t want to pretend I’ve solved this. As if I were enlightened now and could listen perfectly. That would be a pose.

I’m still overwhelmed when someone answers honestly. I still withdraw when it gets too much. I still ask questions I don’t mean.

But I notice it now. See my own patterns. Notice when I hide behind phrases, when I don’t even want to hear the answer.

And sometimes I manage to pause. Not always. But sometimes.

That’s not progress that sells well. No success story. No transformation. Just a slow, laborious becoming aware.

But maybe that’s all we have.

[Awareness doesn’t heal depression](https://www.widerstandskraft.link/en/why-knowing-is-not-enough/). It doesn’t solve social problems. It doesn’t make life easier. But it gives you the chance to act differently. Not always. But sometimes.

Practice. A little more every day.

Not because I want to become a better person. But because I want to become a more attentive one.

---

### \[Paths That Can Carry You – What Really Helps\]

Depression doesn’t run the same course for everyone. Some experience single episodes that subside. Others – like me – live with a chronic companion. For some, highs and lows alternate. For others, the symptoms persist for years.

Life keeps moving. Always. Even when it doesn’t feel like it. Even when you’re sitting in the valley believing there is no way out. The movement of life itself – the ups and downs – can sometimes be comforting. Not because it takes the pain away. But because it means: nothing is final. Neither happiness nor despair.

But there are concrete paths that can help. Not heal. Not redeem. But carry.

**Medication** can be a bridge in the short term – or in the longer term. Antidepressants don’t heal. But they can steady the ground under your feet when everything is giving way. They are not a sign of weakness. They are a tool. And sometimes you need tools so as not to drown.

**Medical help** is necessary. But the way there can seem insurmountable. Making an appointment. Going to the appointment. Talking about it. All of this costs strength you don’t have when you’re sitting in the valley.

**Therapy** is no cure-all. But it can create space to understand the patterns. For chronic depression there are specific approaches such as CBASP, which work directly on relationship patterns that often formed in childhood.

That’s why the most important thing **friends and family** can do is not to give good advice. Not to say encouraging words. But: to become proactive.

Getting someone out of bed. Not metaphorically. Literally. Coming by. Ringing the bell. Staying on it.

Going with someone to the doctor. Making the appointment together. Going along. Waiting outside if necessary. But being there.

Taking someone to the therapist. Sometimes you need someone to go with you, because the way alone is too hard.

These aren’t heroic gestures. They’re small, concrete actions. But they can make the difference between “I can’t do this” and “I’ll try.”

[Depression isolates](https://www.widerstandskraft.link/en/when-the-house-of-cards-collapses/). It makes you believe you’re alone. That you’re too much. That you’re a burden.

But sometimes it’s enough when someone stays. When someone says, “I’ll go with you.” Not: “You can do it.” But: “We’ll go together.”

That’s not a solution. But it’s a beginning.

---

### \[What You Should Know – For Those Affected and Those Close to Them\]

**If you are affected yourself:**

Depression has many layers. Some people experience single episodes that pass. Others live with it for decades. Roughly a fifth to a third of all depressions take a chronic course. That doesn’t mean there can’t be improvement. But it does mean that the idea “it will pass” sometimes isn’t enough.

Many people with depression also have other mental health conditions – anxiety disorders, ADHD, the aftermath of trauma. This is called comorbidity. In fact, more than half of those affected have at least one other diagnosis. That makes treatment more complex. But it doesn’t mean you’re “incurable.” It means you have to find an individual path.

You are not alone. You are not too much. Your pain is real.

**If someone close to you is affected:**

Listen. Without fixing. Without advice. Just be there.

Be proactive. Don’t just ask “What can I do?” – do something. Come by. Bring food. Go with them to the doctor. Stay, even when it’s uncomfortable.

Respect that depression has many faces. Some struggle with it all their lives. That is not a personal weakness. It is the reality of this illness.

And if you yourself are overwhelmed – that’s okay too. Say so. Get support for yourself. You can’t carry everything. But you can be there.

---

### \[Closing\]

I don’t know if depression ever disappears completely. For some, yes. For others, no. For me it is a chronic companion. It grows quieter, then louder again. Sometimes I have months when I can breathe. When I live, not just survive.

And then the days come again when getting up is too hard. When I lie in bed thinking: Not again.

But I know now that life goes on. Not because I’m strong. But because life simply moves. Whether you want it to or not.

In the valleys I don’t need pity. I don’t need big words. No quick solutions.

I just need people who can bear that I’m not doing well. Who don’t immediately try to fix me. Who are simply there. Who listen. Who really hear. Who talk less themselves and give others more space.

Maybe that’s the only thing that counts: that we sometimes stop. That we listen. Not in order to answer, but in order to be there.

I’m practicing this. Failing at it. Practicing again. Like someone learning to walk again – every day, step by step.

And if you know someone who is sitting in the valley right now: go to them. Be there. Listen. And if necessary: take their hand and go with them to the doctor. It helps. Thank you!

![Dorian Rammer laughing into the camera with a thumbs-up, in the cockpit of a helicopter in flight](https://storage.ghost.io/c/e8/5d/e85db032-94da-48a0-8faf-af27af4167bd/content/images/2025/10/c99593ed-7110-42ac-98a9-438a901dbb69.jpeg)

ℹ️

****If you’re in the valley yourself right now:**  
You don’t have to wait until it’s “bad enough.” A phone call is enough as a first step, even in the middle of the night, even without the right words. And if you’re worried about someone else: you can call about that too.  
\- Austria: TelefonSeelsorge ****142** (24/7, free of charge)  
\- Vienna: social-psychiatric emergency service ****01 31 330** (24/7)  
\- Vienna: Crisis Intervention Centre ****01 406 95 95** (weekdays)  
\- Emergency number across the EU: ****112**  
\- USA: ****988** Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (call or text)  
\- UK & Ireland: Samaritans ****116 123**  
\- Other countries: ****findahelpline.com**

---

*Originally published in German as “*[*Wie geht’s? – Eine Frage, die keine Antwort will*](https://www.widerstandskraft.link/wie-gehts-eine-frage-die-keine-antwort-will-depression/)*”. English version by Dorian Rammer, translated with AI assistance.*

👻

****Would you like to support my writing?**  
Even a [**small donation*](https://ko-fi.com/dorianrammer?ref=widerstandskraft.link) helps me set aside time for writing. Thank you.  
  
Warm regards  
****Dorian Rammer**