> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://www.widerstandskraft.link/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# From Nuremberg to Us – and the Burden of Understanding
- URL: https://www.widerstandskraft.link/en/from-nuremberg-to-us-and-the-burden-of-understanding/
- Published: 2026-01-30T16:43:07.000Z
- Updated: 2026-11-03T15:28:52.000Z
- Description: The Nazi leaders at Nuremberg were not monsters but human beings. This text asks what it does to us when perpetrators seem normal, when guilt has no clear face and understanding becomes a burden. A case study in ambivalence, responsibility and the weight of looking closely.
- Author: Dorian Rammer
- Tags: Society & Our Times, Philosophy & Meaning, analytical, #en

**Evil does not wear a uniform.** Often just a suit and a smile. The new film [Nuremberg (2025)](https://www.imdb.com/title/tt29567915/?ref%5F=ext%5Fshr%5Flnk&ref=widerstandskraft.link) with Rami Malek and Russell Crowe made me aware of Douglas Kelley, the US Army psychiatrist who evaluated the defendants at Nuremberg in 1945\. Kelley was looking for monsters. What he found: people. Intelligent, sometimes charming, functioning people. That realization never let go of him, and I understand why.

If you are looking for the bigger picture: my essay [“Evil as a Parasitic Power”](https://www.widerstandskraft.link/en/evil-as-a-parasitic-power/) looks at the gateways of evil and the forces that can push back. This text goes the opposite way. Here, people are at the center. A historical laboratory in which everyday life suddenly stands next to horror. I have been asking similar questions myself for years: how inhumanity arises, how to recognize it, where I would stand under different circumstances. That is why Kelley’s story is more than history to me.

## Nuremberg: A Place Without Monsters

When the high-ranking defendants of the Nuremberg trials were brought to the prison wing of the Palace of Justice in 1945, the world expected monsters. The victorious Allies had put the major war criminals of the Nazi regime on trial: men responsible for millions of deaths. What the world got instead: men in suits, smoking, complaining about the food, polite to the guards. The first shock? Their visible humanity.

Guard duty fell to the *6850th Internal Security Detachment* under Colonel Burton C. Andrus. It was strict: isolation, constant surveillance. Suicide precautions were tightened after Robert Ley took his own life in October 1945\. But the official line was demonstratively correct. The tribunal was meant to show the rule of law, not lynch justice. The message to the world: we are different.

Where people are close to each other every day, something develops. Friction, habituation, sometimes a perverse kind of closeness. Some guards collected autographs. There are reports of gifts, such as a monogrammed handkerchief that Hermann Göring is said to have given to a guard. The “Reichsmarschall” turns back into someone who seems quite kind in personal dealings, or at times actually is. Fraternization was forbidden. It happened anyway. People under stress, in daily contact with “famous names,” become susceptible. Curiosity plays a role, the feeling of being “part of it.” Status works even where everything is set up for control.

## The Man Who Looked Too Closely

Douglas M. Kelley was a US Army psychiatrist who was assigned in 1945 to evaluate the main defendants psychologically. Fitness to stand trial, suicide risk, clinical abnormalities: that was his job. What he did not expect was that these men were not *insane*.

Many people – the public, the military, even scientists – assumed that the leadership of the Nazi regime must have been infected by some kind of “Nazi virus.” A reassuring idea: if they were pathologically possessed, then evil was easier to identify and contain, something outside of us. Kelley looked for pathology, for deviation. What he found: intelligence, narcissism, opportunism – but no convenient label.

His interviews point to an uncomfortable insight. Some of these men were highly intelligent, and they shared certain traits. Kelley named them himself: “overweening ambition, low ethical standards, a strongly developed nationalism which justified anything done in the name of Germandom.” These traits still exist today. People who think in numbers, in quarterly reports, in holding on to power – and for whom human suffering remains an abstract quantity as long as it is not their own.

Hermann Göring in particular became the central figure for Kelley. And his problem. Because Göring was not just anyone. He was a fighter-pilot hero of the First World War and had been addicted to morphine since an injury in the Beer Hall Putsch of 1923\. A power-hungry man with a taste for pomp, and Hitler’s second-in-command. At Nuremberg he tried to treat the courtroom like a stage, and in prison, too, he demanded hierarchy from his fellow inmates.

Kelley had to work with him for months in regular sessions. A kind of “working relationship” developed: Göring was intelligent and manipulative, and he could read people. When Kelley left Nuremberg, Göring wept, as Kelley later wrote. That says something about attachment dynamics: he was losing a counterpart, a mirror. Kelley carried something away that never let go of him: the realization that inhumanity can always be hidden among us. In later writings he stressed again and again that these personality patterns are not unique. They can arise anywhere!

Kelley put it very clearly in a lecture (as quoted by Jack El-Hai). These were “people who exist in every country of the world. Their personality patterns are not obscure. But they are people who have peculiar drives, people who want to be in power.” And then: “I am quite certain that there are people even in America who would willingly climb over the corpses of half of the American public if they could gain control of the other half, and these are the people who today are just talking – who are utilizing the rights of democracy in an anti-democratic fashion.”

No society, he said, is immune to Nazism. He warned his fellow citizens not to vote for candidates who make political capital out of racial or religious differences. His warning went unheard. And today it feels uncomfortably prophetic. In the United States, Trump turns fear into power. In Europe, right-wing movements are gaining ground that use democracy as a vehicle to hollow it out from within. The pattern is rarely new. What is new is only the speed with which it becomes acceptable again.

Perhaps this still hits us so hard because it is more comfortable to believe in clear enemies. That promises safety. And it spares us a look at our own blind spots.

---

Kelley was not alone. Other psychologists and psychiatrists worked with the same men – and came to different conclusions. Some looked for pathology and character disorders where Kelley saw dangerous normality. Others were more interested in biographies and inner logic than in personality patterns. There is no single psychological truth about the guilty. There are frames. But the question remains: *How could it come to this? And could it happen again?*

## Kelley’s Suicide: The Echo of Göring

In 1958, thirteen years after Nuremberg, Douglas Kelley took his own life. With cyanide, the same substance Göring used in 1946 to escape execution.

There are reports of family conflict, alcohol, marital problems. His family denied that the cyanide came “from Nuremberg.” But the symbolism remains. Kelley had once written that he admired Göring “for taking his own life at his own convenience and in a manner of his own choosing.” As an act of self-determination. As a last piece of power over one’s own end. Coincidence is possible. Still, the line remains visible: control was his theme, and cyanide is its most brutal form. A man who spent years thinking about the guilty, and who in the end chose the same gesture as the one he had studied most intensely.

Jack El-Hai, who studied Kelley’s family archive, paints the picture of a brilliant but increasingly unstable man. Overwork, alcohol, and an irritability that became ever harder to control. A pattern of overload, closeness to extremes and a fascination with control that in the end turned against him.

## A Parallel: The Burden of Knowing

In Kelley I recognize a line that also reaches into my own thinking. I have had traumatic experiences: violence, addiction, financial crises, in my own life but also around me. Suicides and suicide attempts. For research purposes, I have again and again studied people who do inhuman things. People who slaughter others without any provocation, sometimes for amusement.

And then at some point you ask yourself: *How are you supposed to act every day as if everything were great?* In the microcosm, the world may be good. But beyond it, so much happens that you have no influence on. You go shopping, enjoy a quiet coffee in a café – while at the same moment, somewhere in the world, someone is being tortured or shot.

Just like Kelley back then, I work today with the same basic question: *How does what we call “evil” come about? How do you recognize it, what is it made of?* For Kelley, it was the direct confrontation with men who carried a system of terror. And who still did not stand out. For me, it is the engagement with violence, trauma, victims and perpetrators. Because without understanding, at some point all you can do is react. And because Kelley recognized something that does not let go of you: you cannot sort out evil in advance. You cannot recognize and identify it from a distance. It simply looks like you and me.

Kelley did not have the tools we have today. No digital resources, no exchange with others. He had to carry much of it alone, along with the pressure of status, an image of masculinity that demands “functioning,” and little social language for “this is getting to me.” You carry themes like guilt and the abyss with you for years, unable to put them down.

Today I have more ways to build something out of it. A nonprofit association I am working to found, various writing projects: an attempt to turn personal experience into something general and effective. A toolbox, not confessional literature. But honestly: it keeps leading back to the same point. To the “face” of what we call inhumanity. It shows itself as something that says a friendly hello.

## Disillusionment Without a Clear Line

This is exactly the disillusionment that hit Kelley in Nuremberg. These men were supposed to be recognizably different. They were not. Humor, intelligence, real self-control in tests and conversations – and still mass suffering clung to them. You can describe this as a moral rupture, what research sometimes calls *moral injury*: a tear in your moral coordinate system. You know too much. And that knowledge cannot be put away again.

I know this dynamic. If you engage with it intensively, at some point you reach this realization: there is no clear line between “us” and “them.” Under certain conditions, many people would be capable of things they cannot imagine today.

**The disillusionment has another dimension.** It concerns not only our image of perpetrators, but also our image of victims. If the former are not clear-cut monsters, then the latter are not automatically free of contradiction. They remain human too, vulnerable and sometimes contradictory. That does not diminish their suffering. But it makes the moral map more complex, and enduring that complexity without blurring responsibility … that costs something!

## How Many Are “Evil from the Start”?

If you say you can understand most of them, the question comes quickly: aren’t there people who are simply “like that”? Psychopaths, different from birth?

There is a small minority with strongly pronounced psychopathic traits. Depending on the measure, it is in the low single-digit percentages, and considerably higher in prisons. This group is disproportionately relevant to violence, but it is not the majority. Most serious crimes come about in other ways: alcohol and disinhibition, addiction. Escalation, socialization into violence, ideology. Even the most severe mental illnesses explain only a smaller share of violent crime at the population level. In most cases there is a path of development that can be reconstructed.

## Tracing the Path

When you speak of “paths” or “development,” it sounds like theory. In truth, though, it is detailed work: you take the biography apart. Childhood, formative experiences. What lessons about power, closeness and violence were learned? Where were the turning points, moments when things could have gone differently? When was a line crossed for the first time, when for the second? What paid off, what went unpunished, what became easier the third time?

You work with documents and testimony. With contradictions. You check self-narratives against facts. [There is almost always a narrative that shrinks one’s own guilt or shifts it elsewhere. Not necessarily a lie, but adjusted](https://www.widerstandskraft.link/en/we-are-what-we-remember-and-how-we-remember-it/) (more on this in my essay on memory). The version you go on living with. That is not a pardon. You can understand how someone got there without saying it was inevitable. You can describe the process without erasing morality.

And while you take all this apart, you must not lose one perspective: that of the victims. Who suffered, and for how long? What was destroyed that cannot be restored? The victims’ perspective is ethically necessary, and methodologically too. Without it, you lose your measure. In the end, responsibility remains. Not as a feeling, but as a point on the map: here was a decision. Here every explanation ends.

And then, as a last question: what would have helped early, before the path hardened? That is not leniency. It is a more precise form of responsibility. Holding explanation and responsibility at the same time, because both are needed: understanding, to prevent. Judging, to draw boundaries.

---

The biggest lie about Nuremberg: that recognizable monsters sat there. The uncomfortable truth: there sat men who made decisions every day. Kelley saw that, and it never let go of him. Perhaps it helped destroy him – the burden of knowing that his warning was not taken seriously. That people preferred to go on believing in clear enemies.

Those who understand how things work can react earlier. Those who do not think in boxes can judge more precisely. But this alertness has a cost. It means not being able to look away when others find it convenient. It means enduring the shades in between. And it means living again and again with the question: where would I be, under different circumstances?

## Conclusion: Understanding Is Not Acquittal

When I write about Nuremberg, about Kelley, about Göring today, it is not purely out of historical interest. The whole thing is almost like a mirror: for the question of how we deal with guilt. And with ourselves.

Kelley’s legacy is ambivalent. His research was valuable, his warning prophetic. But his end shows how dangerous it can be to look too deeply into the abyss, especially without the support you need to find your way back out. Perhaps that is the real lesson: understanding is necessary, but it needs limits. People who bring you back. Spaces where you can set down the incomprehensible before it swallows you. Kelley did not have that. Or not enough of it.

We live in a time when people are reaching for simple enemy images again. Labels stamped on from outside promise order but explain nothing. What remains: looking closely and understanding. To prevent it from happening again, we have to grasp it. There is no safe side. There is only vigilance, responsibility and the daily decision about which side of history you want to stand on.

ℹ️

****If this text weighs on you:**  
No one has to carry the incomprehensible alone. If you are having thoughts of suicide, talk to someone, ideally today.  
\- Austria: TelefonSeelsorge ****142** (24/7, free of charge)  
\- Vienna: social-psychiatric emergency service ****01 31 330**  
\- Emergency number across the EU: ****112**  
\- USA: ****988** Suicide & Crisis Lifeline (call or text)  
\- UK & Ireland: Samaritans ****116 123**  
\- Other countries: ****findahelpline.com**

---

*Originally published in German as “*[*Von Nürnberg zu uns – und die Last des Verstehens*](https://www.widerstandskraft.link/von-nuernberg-zu-uns-und-die-last-des-verstehens/)*”. English version by Dorian Rammer, translated with AI assistance.*